"... [violent revenge] is not the way to go. It will not avenge our son’s
death. Not in our son’s name. Our son died a victim of an inhuman ideology. Our
actions should not serve the same purpose. Let us grieve. Let us reflect and
pray. Let us think about a rational response that brings real peace and justice
to our world. But let us not as a nation add to the inhumanity of our
times."
—Letter to President Bush, from the parents of Greg Rodriguez, who died in
the 9/11 attacks on the World Trade Center
On October 27, 2001, BBC radio aired interviews from the anti-war march held
that day in New York City. According to the reporter, there were approximately
2,000 people in attendance. The reporter interviewed a young man whose
girlfriend had worked on the 84th floor of the World Trade Center. The young man
told the reporter of the phone call his girlfriend had made to him. She said
that they were waiting for assistance in evacuating the building and since she
wasn’t sure she was going to make it, she called to say she loved him and
goodbye. It was the last he heard from her. She is presumed dead.
Yet, he was attending the peace march and the reporter wanted to know why. He
revealed that bombing Afghanistan would not catch the culprits or end terrorism
but would enhance the likelihood of America being the victim of another
terrorist attack. And, like many people who have lost their loved ones in
gruesome ways, he did not wish for anyone else to experience the pain he was
experiencing.
Bombing Afghanistan has definitely done two things: 1) It has increased the
likelihood that America will fall victim to more terrorist attacks because 2) it
is killing unarmed civilians. History should teach America that you cannot drop
"made in USA" bombs on people without them remembering who damaged them. Like
Vito Corleone in the epic film, "The Godfather," who waited until he was well
established in America before going back to his native village in Italy to kill
the don who killed his father, revenge has no statute of limitations and it
never forgets.
The bombing campaign has killed mothers and daughters and sons and parents.
It has killed Mullah Omar’s son. Even those killed by the Taliban for spying and
defecting must be avenged by their families. And if, as the American government
believes, the Taliban is destroyed, the families of those killed by the Taliban
will vent their anger and frustration on those who made their loved ones spy and
defect—the United States of America. Thus, the Bush administration has gotten
the American people involved in a no-win situation. We answer violence with
violence and wonder why, later on, we get more violence. Duh!!
Here we have an administration filled with the best that money can buy. The
best education—Harvard, Yale, Stanford and Princeton graduates fill the Bush
Administration—and the most privileged lifestyles have been lavished upon those
who are running this war.
They’ve all had training in diplomacy and the art of politics. Yet, when all
those skills were desperately needed, the Bush administration failed. Now, those
without Ivy League educations—men who joined the military for subsidized
education—will put their lives on the line to further enrich a handful of
privileged people. They will die for oil and revenge and drugs, but they will
not be dying for freedom, because freedom is being destroyed in the name of
security. In the end, we will live like those wretched souls in the Middle
East.
Over there, death no longer comes from old age, cancer, heart disease or
ill-fated accidents. Over there, death by gruesome acts of violence is an
everyday occurrence. Over there, people of all ages—children, old people, men
and women—die from car bombs and drive-bys and assassination. The violence is so
much and so often that very little in the way of logic and compassion can be
heard through the din.
They call it the Holy Land, yet I find little to nothing holy about a land so
filled with blood. In short, their lives are but brief moments of levity amidst
a lot of grief. This is not the type of lifestyle Americans should be fostering.
But we are today sowing those horrific seeds.
Surely, we are smarter than this. If we ignore the call for peace, we must
understand how our future will be affected. Violence, like drug addiction, is
big enough to take us all.
"Those who would give up essential Liberty, to purchase a little temporary
Safety, deserve neither Liberty or Safety." – Benjamin Franklin.
(Barbara Beebe is a freelance writer based in Fayetteville, N.C.)