Osama bin Laden, twisted mind and all, has won a lot more than he
could have imagined if he masterminded our Sept. 11 disaster. Those
actions kicked off a move to reduce our freedoms here and increase the
numbers of those who hate in the Muslim and Arab world.
The fear of a repeat of a 9/11 type of action by bin Laden followers
has put this country on the chauvinistic course the late Senator Joe
McCarthy tried to put us on about 50 years ago. He felt it was
needed to protect us from the Soviet Empire and "Godless
Communism." McCarthy's logic was proved illogical. Given time, Bush's
logic will prove as illogical.
Among us ,Bush has spread fear of those around the world who
subscribe to Osama bin Laden's view of us as a reason to move this
country from an open and tolerant country to a chauvinistic one where
the welcome mat is withdrawn for non-Whites, Muslims, those with Arabic
names, and those with Middle Eastern looks--whatever that is.
That fear enabled Bush to dust off an unused 1950s law passed
at the high point of our fear of the Soviets as people were actually
building air raid shelters in backyards as protection from an atomic
bomb. The 1950s law allowed for a shadow government to be established
away from D.C., to assure continuity if a bomb wiped out Washington.
Bush is the first president to put that law into action. He did it
without even notifying the third and fourth persons in the presidential
succession line, the Speaker of the House and the president pro tempore
of the Senate. A little flap was raised over that action by Bush, but
because of the fear mode the country is in, congressional leaders muted
their flap.
That same fear mode is what makes us mute dissent and accept long
check-in lines in airports, the government giving some immigrants, legal
or illegal, short term or long term, no slack at all for the smallest
infraction. For instance, a brother from the Ivory Coast,
Tony Oulai, has been detained (kept in jail after jail) since
Sept. 14 as a suspected material witness in the 9/11 terrorist
investigation. There are hundreds of immigrants being held incommunicado
as Tony is; he is the first to get his story out.
The Washington Post's Amy Goldstein had 10 telephone
conversations and a 45-minute visit with him at a jail recently.
Neither Tony nor Amy could figure out why a terrorist plot carried out
by Saudi Arabian Muslim extremists is cause for this 34-year old West
African Roman Catholic to be held in jail without any open
charges against him.
Gallup recently conducted a poll in nine Muslim countries.
There was surprise expressed by our leaders at the negative view the
Muslims have of America. With the way Israel has been using our Apache
helicopters and F-16 airplanes to kill Palestinians and the Afghan
incidents where we attacked and killed friendly civilians, the lack of
U.S. popularity isn’t a surprise.
All of those actions were brought to Muslim TV sets around the world
by the Arabic equivalent of CNN. You can bet that when they see how
their fellow Muslims are faring at the hands of armed forces of
Israel and the U. S., their reactions won't be the same as reactions
here.
For instance, in January the Pentagon reported on a predawn raid by
our troops on a place called Hazar Qadam. The Pentagon reported they
killed 15 and captured 17. A couple of the dead Afghans had their
hands taped behind their back with tape that had USA in big
letters on it.
On that raid, Secretary of Defense Donald Rumsfeld admitted that
there were no Taliban or al-Qaeda fighters among those captured or
killed. According to him, the American servicemen made no mistake; they
were just fed incorrect intelligence about who occupied the site.
He explained that in that type of raid, our troops are trained to
tape the hands of the wounded behind their back and move on. In this
raid's case, the wounded either died from their wounds or were dead when
they were taped. That's the Pentagon's version.
The governor of that province stated that 60 people died in that
raid, not 15. Both of those versions were aired by the media and TV to
both our audience and Muslims around the world.
Which version are the Muslims going to believe? Will they believe Rumsfeld
about the number killed and the reason for taping the hands behind their
back? I don't think so. Gallup's poll found that 61 percent of the
Muslims surveyed didn't even believe that Arabs hijacked the planes that
caused 9/11.
The L.A. Times reported that a young soldier in
the new Afghan army stated that, "It's better for the Americans to leave
our country and go back to their own country."
He also said, "The Americans are cruel. They kill 20 Afghans for one
al-Qaeda member. Yes, of course they have enemies."
That youngster's comments shows that as we kill off hardcore
al-Qaeda members and innocent Afghans, we are enlarging the
pool from which new al-Qaedan types will be drawn. Israel's
actions against the Palestinians are doing the same. Both actions are
creating more individuals who have decided to die for something
positive to them--killing Israelis or Americans.
(Emory Curtis, a freelance writer, can be reached at (916) 961-1859,
fax (916) 967-1866, or via email at eccurtis@hotmail.com.)