The Children Left Behind
The number of AIDS orphans in U.S. to climb,
activists fear
by Saeed Shabazz
The issue of children left behind because their parents have
died of AIDS�so-called AIDS orphans�is a widely discussed
tragedy on the African continent. But in the United States, the
issue rarely is mentioned.
That may be about to change.
"We know that 90 percent of children orphaned by AIDS are
in sub-Saharan Africa. And we know the numbers are increasing in
Asia, the Americas, Central and Eastern Europe and the countries
of the Commonwealth of Independent states," says Philip
Hilton, vice president for Fund Development at the National Black
Leadership Commission on AIDS in New York. "But what we, the
American people, don�t know is that we have a house on fire
right here in our country, right here in New York City."
Mothers taken by AIDS have left behind 6.2 million children
worldwide. In the United States, the Centers for Disease Control
and Prevention (CDC) estimates there are 70,000 to 125,000
children left behind by parents who have died from the disease.
By the end of next year, 58,000 children in New York State will
be orphaned due to maternal deaths from HIV/AIDS, according to the
New York Department of Health. The CDC reports that in New York
City, every hour seven people test positive for AIDS, five of
seven live in Central or East Harlem and three of the five are
Black.
The word AIDS still carries a stigma in the Black community,
says Mr. Hilton, therefore, the fact that children are being left
parentless and the impact on the Black community doesn�t even
appear on the radar screen, he says.
"In fact, the last comprehensive study on the orphaning
issue that I have seen is seven-years-old," he says.
That study, written in 1993 by the Federation of Protestant
Welfare Agencies, is called "Families In Crisis." It
stated that some 50,000 children would be orphaned in New York
City.
The Louisiana State Medical Society also broached the issue in
a 1996 report that stated the AIDS orphan count for the state
"is predicted to range between 1,242 to 2,627 infants and
children by year 2000, and the economic impact on the foster care
system budget could range from $308,112 to $624,546." A
footnote to the report stated that a majority of the children are
Black.
In 1995, the Boston Pediatric AIDS Project released a report
titled "Living Legacy�Planning For Our Children." The
report concluded that orphanages were not the answer because they
remove children from their social origins, therefore, the need is
for acceptable alternatives, such as extended families.
"My mother died of AIDS in July of 1995, she was
43-years-old," says Khadijah Fulwood, 26, of the Bronx. She
says her mother�s death caused her younger brother to try to
commit suicide. She also remembers going to live with her
grandmother when she was seven-years-old, even before her mother,
a heroin user, died.
Ms. Fulwood says that she wishes her mother "could have
been more up front" about her illness. "Maybe I could
have helped her stay on her medication," she says. "I
have been honest with my daughter about what happened to my
mother. I want my child to feel that there is nothing we can�t
talk about.
"To this day my grandmother tells everyone that my mother
died of cancer. She refuses to use the AIDS word," Ms.
Fulwood says.
Even so, it is the elders�the grandparents�who are bearing
the brunt of these children left behind; and they prompted some
AIDS activist groups to begin the discussion about the AIDS
orphans.
The grandmothers began to speak up, says Deborah A. Levine,
vice president for Health and Wellness Strategies, a division of
the Harlem Congregations for Community Improvement, a consortium
of 80 churches. "It was the grandmothers telling their
pastors the problems they faced�their children coming back home
sick and bringing their babies with them," she says.
"And the ministers started listening because the evidence was
mounting � one funeral-at-a-time."
One of the earliest studies in the United States to determine
the prevalence of older surrogate parents was conducted in 1995
and published in the Journal of Community Health. The survey is
called: "The Prevalence of Grandmothers as Primary Caregivers
in a Poor Pediatric Population."
The survey included three clinics in low income neighborhoods
in New York City with high incidences of female HIV/AIDS and
substance abuse. Of the 1,375 families surveyed, eight percent
were headed by grandmothers. Forty-seven percent of those
grandmothers were age 55; twenty-five percent were 60; and eight
percent were 70-years old. Most of them were caring for more than
one child, the study concluded.
The study also said, "the young ages of the children
suggest that many grandparents may continue to be caregivers as
they reach their sixties, seventies and even eighties."
"That is a telling statistic," says Ms. Levine,
adding, "we cannot properly assess the needs of these
families until we know just how bad the problem is, and there is
still no hard data."
What also alarmed the New York AIDS activists is a finding in a
survey released on January 31, 2000: "70 percent of the
people surveyed said that they have never used free health
screenings and over half (51%) would not use them."
The survey indicated inconvenience is a main reason people don�t
use health services. Most facilities are not open after 5 p.m. or
on weekends. Blacks were the most responsive to access health
screenings if free childcare and convenient public transportation
were made available.
"We need a realistic review of this issue," says Mr.
Hilton. "I repeat, we have to get people talking about these
children who are left behind. We have to make sure that the
resources follow the trend of the epidemic. If the grandmothers
are taking care of the children, then that is where the money must
be spent."
Mr. Hilton says the Clinton administration in 1998 earmarked
$10 million for AIDS orphans. The money flowed slowly to the Black
and Latino communities, he says, even though 90 percent of the
children left behind come from minority neighborhoods.
In 1994, an estimated 48,000 U.S. residents died from HIV
infection, statistics show. An estimated 22 percent of the dead
were Black women. Among Black women, heterosexual contact is the
most common mode of HIV transmission, accounting for 38 percent of
new cases. Heterosexual contact has surpassed injection drug use,
although injection drug use is still significant.
Injection drug use also plays a substantial role in HIV
transmission among Black men, more so than among men in general.
Thirty-one percent of new AIDS cases among Black men is due to
injection drug use, compared to 23 percent of all men and 11
percent of white men.
Sex among men is also a significant transmission route
accounting for 32 percent of new cases among Black men, according
to the National Survey of African Americans on HIV/AIDS, a report
by the Kaiser Family Foundation, released in March 1998.
Forty-nine percent of those who died from AIDS in 1998 were
Black men and women, compared to 29 percent in 1990.
"I knew that people were getting AIDS," admits Terese
Amalbert, a mother of two daughters who were 11- and 12-years-old
in 1991, when she learned she was infected. "I used drugs and
I was promiscuous," she says. Ms. Amalbert tries not to think
about dying. "That is why I have become a peer counselor; it
takes up my time and I don�t think about my problem," she
says.
However, she feels a sense of frustration with the system.
"I thought AIDS was something you died from right away. There�s
a lack of education. There was so much I didn�t know. I never
thought I would be alive in the year 2000," she admits.
"Far too many Black women have poor information on how
they can be infected with HIV/AIDS," concurs Dr. Barbara
Justice, a New York-based physician. "It�s long been a
theory of mine that a woman�s lack of access to information
kills just as quickly as lack of access to health care."
The CDC cites three reasons for the rapid spread of HIV/AIDS in
Black and Latino communities: the health disparities between
economic classes, the nation�s inability to successfully deal
with substance abuse and the epidemic of sexually transmitted
diseases.
"AIDS is undermining our capacity as a community to
achieve goals for the development of our children," observes
Mr. Hilton. "Girls whose parents have died often have to care
for their siblings and take on extra work, thereby reducing their
opportunities for schooling. We found this as a parallel issue
throughout the world and in the United States."
"We don�t know about the AIDS orphans because the media
is too busy hyping the news about the new medications. The media
is telling us that people are no longer dying, well that is only
true for white gay males, not for Black and Latino women,"
says Ivy Gamble Cobb, deputy director of the Family Service and
Resource Center in lower Manhattan.
The Family Center is working with 260 families (400 children
and adolescents) to help them prepare for the future�a future
that could mean life at an early age without a mother or father.
"I cannot say that the number (of AIDS orphans) will reach
the 58,000 predicted by the CDC, but I know the number will climb
because we are (going) to hospitals more and more to talk to the
primary parent or parents," Ms. Cobb says.
The CDC seems to agree. The Atlanta-based agency in March
estimated that "750,000 to one million people will have AIDS
in America by 2001," and that one-half of those infected have
not been identified.
"That�s two decades after AIDS exploded into the public
consciousness," observes Ms. Cobb, adding, "50 percent
of the people who were living longer because of the medications
are becoming ill again and we are seeing that many more women are
becoming infected."
"We had these great things happening and they are not
happening any more," says Dr. Jeffrey Laurence, director of
the Laboratory for AIDS Research at New York Hospital/Cornell
Medical College. Before 1995, the AIDS death rate had increased
every year, but between 1995 and 1996, there was a decrease of 42
percent overall, 37 percent for Blacks, he says.
"Everyone cheered and thought this was wonderful�until
the next year," Dr. Laurence remembers.
In 1997-98, the decrease was 19 percent and Dr. Laurence says
that predictions for 1998-99 might show no decrease at all.
"For the 50 percent who were using the medications, the drugs
stop working after about a year-and-a-half," he says.
"We must take ownership of this issue�to put the fire
out�we must work from the inside out," says Philip Hilton.
"As a world community we must stay focused on these children
in Africa and Asia, but people here are not thinking in those
terms when it comes to the United States. We have to get people
here thinking about the children that are being left behind,"
he insists.
|