Black
lawmakers split over Black farmers' plight
by Askia Muhammad
White House Correspondent |
WASHINGTON�In the short space of one week, what started as an
effort by Congressional Black Caucus members to assist Black farmers in
their on-going battle for fair treatment from the U.S. Department of
Agriculture (USDA), has turned into an angry finger-pointing exercise
among CBC members and the only Black Republican House member, with the
farmers stuck in the middle.
At issue: hundreds of millions of dollars that are owed to the
farmers as part of a multi-billion dollar settlement the farmers reached
with the federal government to end a class-action lawsuit accusing the
USDA of racism in making loans and disaster payments, and a fast
approaching deadline for Black claims to be settled. The agency has been
the target of many lawsuits and racial discrimination claims from
employees as well as from farmers.
Nearly 20,000 Black farmers have already applied to receive a portion
of the settlement money. Payments have been approved (but not yet
delivered) to 13,000 of those claimants, according to CBC members,
citing USDA figures.
"We hope to strike a disabling blow to the continued
discrimination at the USDA, to ensure that this discrimination will
never again raise its ugly head," Rep. Eva Clayton (D-N.C.) told
reporters June 14, when she and several of her CBC colleagues introduced
three bills intended to "give hope to the farmers and USDA
employees, who for more than four decades have suffered under a system
that was designed to protect them."
Just five days later, surrounded by dozens of Black farmers from
throughout the South, Rep. J.C. Watts (R-Okla.) chairman of the House
Republican Conference, accused the CBC members of "playing
politics."
"America�s Black farmers deserve our united support," Mr.
Watts said June19, vowing to reintroduce a non-binding House resolution
with no legal authority, which called for speedier payments to the
farmers. A similar resolution was defeated in May, with CBC members
voting solidly against it. "We must reject those who attempt to
play politics with their plight for purely political gain," Mr.
Watts said.
Members of the Black Farmers Agriculturists Association (BFAA) joined
the fray, vowing to punish CBC members who did not support the
Republican-backed resolution. "We have representatives here from
most of the (21) BFAA chapters who have told stories of disappointment
with their Black congressional representatives on issues that concern
them in their states," BFAA President Gary Grant told the
Juneteenth Day rally in front of the U.S. Capitol.
Specifically, disgruntled Black farmers from Georgia promised to
withhold their support for the re-election of Rep. Sanford Bishop (D-Ga.),
citing his vote against the non-binding resolution, among other
complaints.
Just three days later, CBC members convened again to "set the
record straight" concerning the "consistent role" the CBC
has played in seeking relief for the Black farmers.
Rep. Bishop also defended his efforts in behalf of Black farmers. He
does not, he said, understand why his outspoken critics "choose to
misspeak the truth," Mr. Bishop said in response to a question from
The Final Call. "As we get further down the election trail,
we may find out what (their) motives are."
A number of other CBC members "made it absolutely clear that
this was a top priority issue," Rep. Maxine Waters (D-Cal.), former
CBC chairperson said. "The members of the CBC joined with Black
farmers from all over the country.
"We literally took the Attorney General by the hand and the
Agriculture Secretary by the hand and helped forge the language and the
strategy for waving the statute of limitations," that had expired
in part because of the racially discriminatory actions of USDA staff and
which threatened to leave the Black farmers landless, and without
compensation, Rep. Waters said.
CBC members noted that they were instrumental in arranging meetings
for the farm leaders with President Bill Clinton, as well as various
USDA officials. As a result of CBC efforts, in June 1998 Black Farmer
Statute of Limitations legislation passed, with $40 million in funding.
Shortly thereafter, the historic "Pigford v. Glickman" class
action lawsuit against USDA was settled.
"The press thinks that just because someone has a Black face or
Black skin that gives them some kind of instant credibility to speak on
behalf of the Black community," Rep. Mel Watt (D-N.C.) told
reporters. "I�ve never taken a partisan shot, a racial shot, a
personal shot at J.C. Watts," Mr. Watt said, calling the Republican
leader his "good friend" and pointing out that because of the
similarity in the spelling of their names they often mistakenly receive
mail addressed to one another.
"But the nerve of somebody coming forward who has, up to this
point disavowed any representational interest in the Black community,
hasn�t even been willing to join the Congressional Black Caucus, and
now comes forward and says �I�m going to speak on behalf farmers,
when I haven�t done a thing,� is just outrageous," Mr. Watt
said.
"Anybody who thinks that the Republicans are interested in
helping the Black farmer, is tantamount to the chicken voting for
Colonel Sanders," said Rep. Bennie Thompson (D-Miss.). "The
record is clear. We have always been interested, as a party, and as a
Caucus, in helping solve the plight of the Black farmer. We�re not
where we want to be, but we�re a long way from where we used to
be."
By the end of the day Rep. Watts, the Republican, was offering an
olive branch, in the form of praise for past CBC efforts, and calling
for a return to bi-partisan cooperation. "It is important to note
the CBC�s efforts" concerning Black farmers "have been very
honorable and commendable, and Black farmers owe them a debt of
gratitude for their work," Mr. Watts said in statement following
the CBC press conference.
The Republican leader once again called on CBC members to support
another Republican-backed, non-binding resolution concerning farm
payments. CBC officials denounced the measure as "pablum,"
vowing to once again oppose it.
Instead, they called for the GOP leadership to support the "real
food" contained in three "substantive" proposals made by
CBC members to: restructure USDA policies and hold the agency
"accountable;" protect the civil rights of all small farmers;
and to resolve employee disputes at the agency which is nicknamed
"the last plantation."
Black farmers, meanwhile, would not renounce their new friends in the
GOP. "Farmers are upset. Farmers see nothing, other than the fact
that they don�t have any money," John Boyd, National Black
Farmers Association president told The Final Call after the CBC
press conference. "We have been strategizing how we can get a bill
out, between the majority and the minority, that can help the farmers
get some immediate results before the Fourth of July."
"The farmers deserve a final solution," BFAA executive
director Sam Taylor added. "They should not have to come back to
Washington for this matter. The Black Caucus credentials are not at
stake here. They have fought valiantly. The issue is not the
partisanship." Mr. Taylor proposed cooperation among CBC members
and the Republican leadership.
"If J.C. Watts is opening up the door," Mr. Boyd added,
"we�re going have to walk through it." |